Trump and Nader not
so opposite
by DC Larson
Legendary citizens' rights activist Ralph Nader and
globally influential business titan Donald Trump
might seem miles apart.
But I believet that in fundamental ways, they are not.
In 2004, I was Nader's paid Iowa coordinator. And in
2000 and 2008, I volunteered for his third party and
independent presidential campaigns. I also co -
founded the Iowa Green Party and served as its
state Media Coordinator. I left the Greens in 2004
to work for the independent Nader campaign.
I am proud of those efforts to open up the democratic
process to more ideologically diverse citizen
representation.
Today, I support Republican nomination candidate Donald
Trump. I will be caucusing for him here in Iowa, and only recently
changed my registration from "independent" to "Republi -
can" for that very purpose.
I am motivated by the same reverence for long -
established Constitutional principles and safeguards
that inspired my earlier toil for Nader.
(Ralph Nader appreciates Trump's potential to disrupt the
two-party status quo, I understand, though he himself
does not endorse Trump's candidacy. Both men decry a
major party structure that seeks through rule manipu -
lations and outright anti-voter actions to stifle genuine,
meaningful citizen participation in government -- more on
that, later. )
In advocating their causes, Nader and Trump each
depend on the same Constitution as legal flooring. Both
cite established Constitutional principles like national
sovereignty and defending citizen liberty.
Nader opposed the authority wielded by the World Trade
Organization, that globally-oppressive, shadowy, and
democratically unaccountable group that was empowered
to rule over nations' locally passed environmental and
workplace laws.
Nader had for decades defended citizens against predatory
corporate practices. He later turned that same public-interest
spotlight on the major parties' indifference to citizen welfare and
their lock on the electoral process. That last instantly enraged
a Democrat Party that had long celebrated him. The icon was
immediately ostracized, even falsely blamed for the 2000
election's outcome.
Then, following the 2004 election, it was revealed that an
under the table, state-by-state 'Stop Nader' scheme had
been cooked up by Democrats at the national level. Across
the country (including here in Iowa), nuisance suits were
filed challenging Nader's ballot access. Their actual purpose
was to drain his campaign of both funds and energies,
and to stifle his independent voice.
We see today similar anti-public interest skullduggery as
fading GOP dinosaurs and their news media cohorts join
forces to kneecap not only Trump but his supporters and the
very notion of stepping out of status quo formation.
Donald Trump challenges the ruling beltway party /
mainstream media machine that wheezes its dusty
dictums at distant remove from actual American
citizens. For evidence of that yawning divide, consider
that national polls uniformly place Trump far ahead of
his competitors despite the political press belittling and
even vilifying Trump and his supporters at every
opportunity.
Indeed, in reading recently of the establishment GOP
(John Sununu, Bill Kristol, George Will, South Carolina
Governor Nikki Haley) mounting attacks on the populist
Trump campaign, and even organizing efforts to
challenge his ballot status in some states, I am
reminded of the Democrats' 2004 anti-Nader
efforts.
One today reads of state Republican organizations
seeking to challenge Trump's ballot status, and of the
Virginia GOP effort to require primary voters to sign
party 'loyalty oaths.'
In his 2002 "Crashing the Party," Nader wrote, "In no
Western democracy are the hurdles for candidates to
access the ballot anywhere near as high as ours."
For his part, Trump tweeted recently of the Virginia anti -
voter shenanigans, "It begins. Republican Party of
Virginia, controlled by the RNC, is working hard to disallow
independent, unaffiliated, and new voters. BAD!"
Two other parallels: Both Nader and Trump opposed the
George W. Bush administration's Iraq invasion. (I
was part of a pre-invasion bus caravan to Washington, DC
that joined some half-million marching through that city,
urging against invasion.)
And each man has decried the unpatriotic motives that
lead American corporations' to relocate in foreign lands.
Now, I have evolved a bit since my time working for
Ralph Nader. While I still hold firm to the ideals that
drove me, I've come to appreciate that without vigorously
maintained and fiscally blooming national sovereignty,
desired advancements are without guarantee.
I understand, too, that national patriotism is not a
negative, but a natural, healthy component of the public
interest. Pride in one's country and concern for those
genuinely in need are not at all mutually exclusive.
It is entirely appropriate for Americans to be proud of
national accomplishments, strengths, and ideals. To see
the glass as half full and not half empty. To acknowledge
historic mistakes and shortcomings, but to remember
that such are deviations from our shared noble arc, and
hardly define us.
And that for any justice for American citizens to be
meaningful, citizenship status must be clearly, legally
defined, and not simply doled out indiscriminately.
America has traditionally been a force for justice in the
world, a beacon of light. If it were otherwise, millions
would not seek to live here.
Donald Trump wants to return our country to a global
position of unassailable strength and respect. And I will
be as proud caucusing for him as I was endeavoring for
Nader.
Formerly of Marshalltown, Waterloo's DC (David) Larson writes
the retro-styled Eddie Atomic Space Adventure series. He was
on the staffs of Pin Up America and Rockabilly magazines, and
accumulated freelance credits including Counterpunch, Goldmine,
USA Today, Daily Caller, No Depression, the Huffington Post, and
American Thinker.
This essay appeared in other forms in Iowa papers the Marshalltown
Times-Republican and Waterloo-Cedar Falls Courier, as well as on
the author's political blog, AmericanSceneMagazine,blogspot.com.