Obey laws as they exist today
Five people snuck into a movie theater. Should staff kick them out, or welcome them to remain and enjoy the movie?
Democrats insist non-citizens who've invaded our country be allowed to "remain and enjoy the movie."
They advocate that illegal aliens be allowed to cast ballots in our elections, sit on juries, even serve in elected office. That prompts this question: What rights should America's legal citizens have in our own country, that non-citizens shouldn't?
Americans need to think carefully about this. It affects our entire nation - its job opportunities, social, medical, and educational services' sustainability, cultural and legal integrity.
We should ask ourselves: What's the significance of citizenship?
Advocates of granting legal citizenship to illegals sometimes argue that such has become their rightful due, as illegals may have lived for years in the United States.
Consider the principle of legal ownership status in another context:
Five years ago, Roy stole a blue car in Philadelphia. Today, he is still driving it. Because five years have passed, is the car now legitimately Roy's, or does it remain stolen property?
Voices demanding that citizenship be extended to scofflaw non-citizens insist that illegals who were brought into this country when they were children are without culpability, as they know no other life, no other country. Advocates also point to possible past economic contributions.
Consider, then, another hypothetical:
After having stolen the blue Philadelphia car, Roy gives it to Pete. Though initially unaware that Roy had stolen it, Pete does later realize that. It is the only car Pete has ever had. And over the course of several years of driving it and enjoying its benefits, Pete spent considerable cash on gas, oil, and general mechanical upkeep.
Do those factors make the car no longer the bounty of criminality, and somehow Pete's rightful property?
Of course not.
Some might object to that comparison, and argue citizenship is not a material commodity. But all rights are properties. The freedoms of religion and association cannot be taken off the shelf, physical elements examined. Yet they have value.
In the same way, legal citizenship status is a good.
One might think a current law broken, and at some future point likely to be changed. But that doesn’t justify ignoring its present actuality. No society can survive as an orderly institution if everyone picks which laws to respect and which to disregard.
People today should obey laws that exist today.
.jpg)


